New foragers sometimes worry about telling the difference between highly sought-after ramps (wild leeks) and their poisonous look-alikes, Lily-of-the-valley. It’s always wise to be leery when you’re new to foraging, but once you know what to look for you don’t need to worry. There are quite a few ways to accurately tell the difference between the two plants.
Ramps (ramsons in the UK) are alliums, members of the onion family. Their leaves taste like a milder mixture of garlic and onion, and once cooked they have the texture of spinach. They have a short season and are difficult to cultivate, which means that they fetch top dollar at farmers’ markets — up to $20 a pound.
In contrast, Lily-of-the-valley is an imported flower that has invasive habits and contains cardiac glycosides that affect the body in a similar manner to foxglove (digitalis). Symptoms of ingesting it include flushed skin, nausea, dizziness, headache, weakness, hallucinations and changes in heart rate. In extreme cases, it can lead to death. Most cases of poisoning by Lily-of-the-valley result from children eating the berries that occur later in the season, but occasionally there are cases of poisoning where people mistakenly cook with them, thinking they are ramps.
The two plants look similar, but there are good ways to tell them apart. You can see some differences right away and there are even more ways to be sure you’re picking ramps and not lily-of-the-valley.
- Look at the roots. Ramps emerge from a bulb and have rootlets at the very end of it. Lily-of-the-valley do not have bulbs but have longer roots with rootlets along the length.
- Look at the leaves. Ramps have one or two leaves that emerge separately from the ground, each on its own stem. Lily-of-the-valley has a stem that appears and multiple leaves that are whorled around the center.
- Look at the flowers. Ramps do not have a flower stem until later in the season. The lily-of-the-valley flower stem appears almost as soon as the leaves unfold. Once the flowers emerge (generally after the season for harvesting ramps), the flowers look very different. Ramp flowers are small daisy-like clusters with green centers at the end of a stalk, while Lily-of-the-valley have many small bell-shaped flowers that hang down from the length of the stalk.
- Look at the site. Ramps grow on the floor of moist, open woodlands. Lily-of-the-valley is a domestic plant which likes the same soil, but is usually found on old farm sites and around homes.
- Pay attention to the time of year. Ramps emerge earlier in the year. They typically come up when Lily-of-the-valley are just breaking the ground in very early spring.
- Smell it. Smell is the easiest identifier by far. Tear the leaf — ramps smell very strongly of onion and garlic. Lily-of-the-valley has no smell when the leaves are torn.
It’s a good idea to locate and dig up a lily-of-the-valley so you can see and smell the differences for yourself. The best way is to forage with someone who has experience with ramps your first time out. That said, if you use these identifiers it is easy to tell the difference. Be sure to never eat anything that you are not sure about, however.
Ramps are extremely slow to reproduce, which means it’s important to forage for them responsibly. In some parts of the country they are over-harvested and it is illegal to harvest them in parts of Canada. Be sure to only harvest the leaves and not the bulbs, so the plants survive. Even then, harvest only a small percent of the leaves you find. This can help ensure that the stand can continue on for many years.
Once you have your ramps, here are wonderful ways to cook with them.
Micki J G'Fellers(May 7, 2017 - 5:26 pm)
Do you send out a newsletter? If so count me in. Thank you.
How to cook with ramps | A Magical Life(March 12, 2018 - 10:19 pm)
[…] If you’re not 100% sure of how to identify ramps (it’s quite easy once you know the telltale signs), check out How to tell the difference between ramps and lily-of-the-valley. […]
What We're Foraging This Week (5/14) | A Magical Life(May 14, 2018 - 7:38 pm)
[…] sure how to tell ramps from lily of the valley or other plants? Here are the easy ways to positively ID them. Not sure how to cook them? Here are our favorite ways to cook with […]
Wild Ramp Seasoning Salt - A Magical Life(April 9, 2019 - 3:16 pm)
[…] If you’re not familiar with ramps, you can check out our post on finding wild ramps and telling them apart from poisonous lily of the valley. […]
Stephansuch(April 5, 2020 - 4:18 am)
Your picture was perfect for me to tell the difference. Found a patch of green today that turned out to be lillies.
Tortellini with ramps, sage and brown butter - Kitchen Table Food(May 5, 2020 - 8:22 am)
[…] the right ones. Ramps look a lot like the poisonous Lily-of-the-Valley, so don’t mix them up (click here to see the difference). An important difference: the leafs of ramps smell like garlic (tear one […]